Hi everyone,
So I have just finished a photography course organized by Magnum photos. 5 days of intensive photography with Peter Marlow of Magnum fame.
We shot projects that we pitched ourselves on the first day and exhibited them on the last day, working with Marlow along the way.
During that course, I showed my previous work to the Magnum guys and especially the portrait book that I am working on using Blurb which will include shots like these:
"These are not portraits" said Marlow. "These are faces. And they are a bit too accidental if you ask me" he said.
"How do you mean" I said. "Well you've just come across these people on the street and stuck a camera in their faces."
"exactly, that's the whole point" I said. "There isn't much value to that" he replied. "look at Steve McCurry, he finds his subjects and then puts them in backgrounds and light environments he feels comfortable in"…
I always thought that McCurry's shots, amazing and inspiring as they may be, felt a bit too staged and I got my confirmation right there.
Coming from a Magnum photographer, all this got me thinking… Is there really no value in trying to bring people's emotions and personalities through their eyes and faces?
Is there only value in portraits like the ones below where the surrounding, background, framing tell a bit more about the person what they do etc?
I read again McCurry's chapter in the Magnum Stories book where he says "There's got to be purpose to the portrait at another level - You have to say something or reveal something about the person. Recording a face isn't enough".
Why not?
Magnum was founded as a rebellion against the establishment because Capa, Cartier Bresson were angry not to be able to own their negatives.
Interesting how they have become the establishment over 50 years.
I really need your honest views and opinions on this. I am at a critical stage where I am putting my/your favorite portraits/faces in a book that I am planning on publishing through Blurb. Is there no point for such a book? What do you think of "Accidental Faces" for a title?