Parent Reviews
Sort by:
August 3, 2016
Irresponsible Sex Lesson
Although I believe girls 13 and above would be okay reading this book (with perhaps parental footnote) which I will explain later. This book was recommended summer reading for my 10 year old. That is way too young. This book is told in the POV of four 15-16 year old girls. There is drinking, skinny-dipping, death, suicide. Shall I say more?
Okay I will. The most disturbing part for me was a 15 year old girl seducing her 19 year old soccer coach. I believe in this country that is considered Statutory Rape. And okay, while as an adult, I can understand the nuances, and the lesson the girl learned, and the apologies made, and the regret, and ALL that. Here is the problem. While it dealt with her emotional regret, it never mentioned if the guy wore a condom, or the fact that sometimes in life, having sex can lead to deeper consequences like Sexually Transmitted Disease OR Pregnancy.
So for me, this was an irresponsible bit of literature.
6 people found this helpful.
Report this review
July 30, 2024
Report this review
February 4, 2023
amazing movie
Report this review
May 10, 2018
Great for kids
This book is the best book I've ever read i haven't seen the movies but I've been dying to. There are some inappropriate words but you have to learn them sometime in life.
Report this review
June 12, 2017
Meh
*Christian Review*
Been a few years since I watched it.
Deals with issues such as death quite a bit, young love, kissing and there is also a witchcraft scene by memory. Can't remember language or violence. But could've been.
There was no sex but it does happen off screen with Bridget (pre-martial). Bridget flirts heavily and acts sexy to get a guy (her coach) and goes in club underage with her coach. I don't feel this is suitable for Christians. Friendship is ok message in film. Death message is ok.
Report this review
March 18, 2016
A touching and heartfelt coming-of-age film
I felt there are many positive messages in this movie. Hearts soften, personal walls are torn down, characters find new strength and purpose, and friends encourage and support each other.
I read several negative reviews about the fact that one of the girls loses her virginity, which is true. It is not shown, (other than a few seconds of passionate kissing, both characters fully-clothed) but you understand that it happened. I feel it is important to point out that the occurrence is not glorified or glamorized. If it had been, I would have negative things to say. However, I felt it was handled well and it was made clear to the viewers - and the girl's peers - that she was heading down a dangerous path with her bold flirtations. (*possible spoilers*) The young man she was flirting with even realized she was coming on too strong at times and walked away. When they both did get carried away, it was clear that it was a mistake, not to just the viewers, but to the two characters, as well. In fact, the girl is shown feeling empty after it happened. I felt that the whole thing opened up the possibility for some meaningful conversation and teaching moments between parents and their teens about the consequences of our actions and how attractions can be carried too far.
Some reviewers also mention a second girl losing her virginity, but if that's the case, it's not obvious. She and a young man are alone on a boat at night, but there is nothing more than a few seconds of kissing at one point (again, they are also fully clothed). It's left up to the viewer to decide if anything more happened between them.
As far as any other sensuality goes, there are a couple of scenes in which you see some of the girls in their underwear but in the context of changing pants and going swimming. I could have done without it, but it was not done in a sensual way. You also see a young man with his shirt off in the context of swimming. Later, you see drawings of him with his shirt off and I was more uncomfortable with the drawings than seeing him swimming with no shirt on.
One thing I had a little difficulty with (*possible spoiler*) was seeing an engaged couple living together like a happy family before they were married. I realize some people don't see that as an issue, so it depends on the viewer's personal point of view, but I felt that portraying a couple living together before they were married as being a positive - or normal - thing sent a less desirable message than the portrayal of young people getting carried away, making a mistake and feeling remorse.
There is some smoking, done by adult employees on their work break, not by any main character. There is also brief drinking and evidence of drinking by the soccer coaches after work hours. No one got drunk. Three young people sneak out to go to a club, but they do not drink.
The only thing that prevented me from giving this movie one more star is the unnecessary profanity. Granted, it is more mild than many other movies, but I felt that it was not necessary and was a bit excessive.
I enjoyed this film. I love how diverse each of the girls are. I think teenage girls could relate to at least one of the four main characters with their flaws and their personal and family struggles. The film deals with divorce and loss of loved ones and portrays friends coming together, encouraging each other to express their grief, helping each other get through their challenges. Overall, it left me feeling uplifted. I've seen it twice so far and would watch it again.
Report this review
July 18, 2010
Report this review
July 18, 2010
Oh hate it so much
Report this review
November 21, 2009
OK for tweens
Loved the movie. It followed the book very well. There is an allusion of a seductive scene in Greece, but nothing risque. The messages are positive, and through everything, friendships are built stronger through separation and experience. The girls come together in the end to reflect on their experiences which brings the movie to a nice close.
Report this review
July 7, 2009
APPORPRITE
Report this review
What to Watch Next
Common Sense Media's unbiased ratings are created by expert reviewers and aren't influenced by the product's creators or by any of our funders, affiliates, or partners.
See how we rate