Carbazole- and indole-labeled phospholipids have been used to monitor the homo- or heterogeneity of lipid mixing in several types of lipid bilayers combining a brominated and a nonbrominated lipid with varying amounts of cholesterol. Experimental quenching curves (relating the normalized probe fluorescence intensity to the mole fraction of brominated lipid) show a characteristic smooth, monophasic form for homogeneous liquid-crystalline lipid mixtures. However, for mixtures exhibiting lipid lateral segregation, such curves show marked perturbations in form over the region of composition where segregation occurs. Using this approach, it is found that high mole fractions of cholesterol (40-50 mol %) promote the formation of apparently homogeneous solutions in mixtures of disaturated and monounsaturated phosphatidylcholines (PCs) that exhibit extensive thermotropic phase separations in the absence of sterol. At only slightly lower levels of cholesterol, however, these systems exhibit inhomogeneous lipid mixing over a wide range of relative proportions of the two PC components. Mixtures of cerebroside and monounsaturated PCs, even at high bilayer cholesterol contents, exhibit significant inhomogeneity in lipid mixing over a wide range of cerebroside/PC ratios. Phase-separating PC/PC and PC/cerebroside mixtures can readily form long-lived metastable solutions when the level of the higher-melting component in the liquid-crystalline phase exceeds its equilibrium solubility by as much as 20-30 mol %; this tendency is significantly increased by cholesterol. Cholesterol shows no significant ability to enhance lipid intermixing in a third type of phase-separating lipid system, combining a monounsaturated PC with a monounsaturated phosphatidic acid--calcium complex. Experiments using cleavable phospholipid conjugates, linking a fluorescent lipid to a brominated lipid, suggest that each fluorescent molecule probes a local lipid domain comprising approximately less than 40-50 nearby acyl chains.