Developing effective anti-fibrotic therapies for heart diseases holds the potential to address unmet needs in several cardiac conditions, including heart failure with preserved ejection fraction, hypertrophic cardiomyopathy, and cardiotoxicity induced by cancer therapy. The inhibition of the primary fibrotic regulator, transforming growth factor (TGF) β, represents an efficient strategy for mitigating fibrosis in preclinical models. However, translating these findings into clinical benefits faces challenges due to potential adverse effects stemming from TGF-β's physiological actions in inflammation and tissue homeostasis. Various strategies exist for inhibiting TGF-β, each associated with a distinct risk of adverse effects. Targeting TGF-β directly or through its signaling pathway proves efficient in reducing fibrosis. However, direct TGF-β blockade may lead to uncontrolled inflammation, especially following myocardial infarction, while interference with the signaling pathway may compromise structural integrity, resulting in issues like insufficient wound healing or ventricular dilatation. Influencing TGF-β activity through interacting signaling pathways, for instance by inhibitors of the renin-angiotensin-aldosterone-system, is insufficiently potent in reducing fibrosis. Targeting activators of latent TGF-β, including ADAMTS enzymes, thrombospondin, and integrins, emerges as a potentially safer strategy to reduce TGF-β-induced fibrosis but it requires the identification of appropriate targets. Encouragement is drawn from promising agents developed for fibrosis in other organs, fueling hope for similar breakthroughs in treating cardiac fibrosis. Such advances depend on overcoming obstacles for the implementation of anti-fibrotic strategies in patients with heart disease, including fibrosis quantification. In this review, insights garnered from interventional and mechanistic studies, obtained through a non-systemic search spanning preclinical and clinical evidence, are summarized to pinpoint the most promising targets for further exploration and development.