The benzoylthiophene analog, PD 81,723, has been shown to allosterically enhance agonist binding and functional activation of the mammalian adenosine (ADO) A(1) receptor subtype by putatively maintaining the receptor in a high affinity state. The present studies were conducted to evaluate the ability of PD 81,723 to enhance the binding of [3H]cyclohexyladenosine ([3H]CHA) to A(1) receptors of neural (cerebral cortex) and non-neural (adipocyte) origin in three different species; rat, guinea pig and dog. PD 81, 723 (0.3-100 microM) produced a concentration-dependent enhancement of [3H]CHA binding to rat brain A(1) receptors. These effects were also species-dependent with larger enhancements (150-200% of control) observed in guinea pig and dog brain membranes as compared to the rat (120% of control). In contrast, PD 81,723 did not produce any enhancement of [3H]CHA binding to A(1) receptors in adipocyte membranes from any of the species examined. Additional binding studies were conducted using pharmacological manipulations that have previously been shown to enhance the allosteric effects of PD 81,723. In the presence of 1 mM GTP, the allosteric effects of PD 81,723 (15 microM) were increased in rat, guinea pig and dog brain membranes, however, in adipocyte membranes from each species, no significant alteration in agonist binding was observed. Similarly, the A(1) receptor selective antagonist 8-cyclopentyl-1, 3-dipropylxanthine (added to effectively reduce the intrinsic antagonist properties of PD 81,723) was found to enhance the allosteric effects of PD 81,723 (15 microM) in brain, but produce no alteration of agonist binding in adipocyte membranes from each species. Examination of the dissociation kinetics of [3H]CHA binding from rat brain and adipocyte membranes revealed that PD 81,723 (15 microM) differentially slowed agonist dissociation from brain, but not adipocyte, membranes. Taken together, the present data support the hypothesis that in tissues that are sensitive to PD 81,723, this benzyolthiophene functions to maintain the A(1) receptor in a high-affinity state and that the relative proportions of high-affinity A(1) receptors present in specific tissues may contribute, at least in part, to the apparent differential effects of PD 81,723 on agonist binding. The tissue specific modulation of A(1) receptor function by PD 81,723 also illustrates the possibility that the locus of allosteric modulation by PD 81,723 may be manifest via a specific, but indirect and tissue-dependent, interaction with the A(1) receptor.