Skip to content
This repository has been archived by the owner on Apr 22, 2020. It is now read-only.

azure: phase1 add routeTableName to azure.json #172

Conversation

colemickens
Copy link
Contributor

I changed a small something in the cloudprovider code I'm about to send a PR for; this is the corresponding change for bring-up.

@mikedanese
Copy link
Contributor

LGTM

@mikedanese mikedanese merged commit 7eca133 into kubernetes-retired:master Jul 12, 2016
k8s-github-robot pushed a commit to kubernetes/kubernetes that referenced this pull request Jul 27, 2016
Automatic merge from submit-queue

Add an Azure CloudProvider Implementation

This PR adds `Azure` as a cloudprovider provider for Kubernetes. It specifically adds support for native pod networking (via Azure User Defined Routes) and L4 Load Balancing (via Azure Load Balancers).

I did have to add `clusterName` as a parameter to the `LoadBalancers` methods. This is because Azure only allows one "LoadBalancer" object per set of backend machines. This means a single "LoadBalancer" object must be shared across the cluster. The "LoadBalancer" is named via the `cluster-name` parameter passed to `kube-controller-manager` so as to enable multiple clusters per resource group if the user desires such a configuration.

There are few things that I'm a bit unsure about:

1. The implementation of the `Instances` interface. It's not extensively documented, it's not really clear what the different functions are used for, and my questions on the ML didn't get an answer.

2. Counter to the comments on the `LoadBalancers` Interface, I modify the `api.Service` object in `EnsureLoadBalancerDeleted`, but not with the intention of affecting Kube's view of the Service. I simply do it so that I can remove the `Port`s on the `Service` object and then re-use my reconciliation logic that can handle removing stale/deleted Ports. 

3. The logging is a bit verbose. I'm looking for guidance on the appropriate log level to use for the chattier bits.

Due to the (current) lack of Instance Metadata Service and lack of Virtual Machine Identity in Azure, the user is required to do a few things to opt-in to this provider. These things are called-out as they are in contrast to AWS/GCE:

1. The user must provision an Azure Active Directory ServicePrincipal with `Contributor` level access to the resource group that the cluster is deployed in. This creation process is documented [by Hashicorp](https://www.packer.io/docs/builders/azure-setup.html) or [on the MSDN Blog](https://blogs.msdn.microsoft.com/arsen/2016/05/11/how-to-create-and-test-azure-service-principal-using-azure-cli/).

2. The user must place a JSON file somewhere on each Node that conforms to the `AzureConfig` struct defined in `azure.go`. (This is automatically done in the Azure flavor of [Kubernetes-Anywhere](https://github.com/kubernetes/kubernetes-anywhere).)

3. The user must specify `--cloud-config=/path/to/azure.json` as an option to `kube-apiserver` and `kube-controller-manager` similarly to how the user would need to pass `--cloud-provider=azure`.

I've been running approximately this code for a month and a half. I only encountered one bug which has since been fixed and covered by a unit test. I've just deployed a new cluster (and a Type=LoadBalancer nginx Service) using this code (via `kubernetes-anywhere`) and have posted [the `kube-controller-manager` logs](https://gist.github.com/colemickens/1bf6a26e7ef9484a72a30b1fcf9fc3cb) for anyone who is interested in seeing the logs of the logic.

If you're interested in this PR, you can use the instructions in my [`azure-kubernetes-demo` repository](https://github.com/colemickens/azure-kubernetes-demo) to deploy a cluster with minimal effort via [`kubernetes-anywhere`](https://github.com/kubernetes/kubernetes-anywhere). (There is currently [a pending PR in `kubernetes-anywhere` that is needed](kubernetes-retired/kubernetes-anywhere#172) in conjuncture with this PR). I also have a pre-built `hyperkube` image: `docker.io/colemickens/hyperkube-amd64:v1.4.0-alpha.0-azure`, which will be kept in sync with the branch this PR stems from.

I'm hoping this can land in the Kubernetes 1.4 timeframe.

CC (potential code reviewers from Azure): @ahmetalpbalkan @brendandixon @paulmey

CC (other interested Azure folk): @brendandburns @johngossman @anandramakrishna @jmspring @jimzim

CC (others who've expressed interest): @codefx9 @edevil @thockin @rootfs
@colemickens colemickens deleted the azure-add-route-table-to-azurejson branch August 17, 2016 22:08
dims pushed a commit to dims/openstack-cloud-controller-manager that referenced this pull request Mar 24, 2017
Automatic merge from submit-queue

Add an Azure CloudProvider Implementation

This PR adds `Azure` as a cloudprovider provider for Kubernetes. It specifically adds support for native pod networking (via Azure User Defined Routes) and L4 Load Balancing (via Azure Load Balancers).

I did have to add `clusterName` as a parameter to the `LoadBalancers` methods. This is because Azure only allows one "LoadBalancer" object per set of backend machines. This means a single "LoadBalancer" object must be shared across the cluster. The "LoadBalancer" is named via the `cluster-name` parameter passed to `kube-controller-manager` so as to enable multiple clusters per resource group if the user desires such a configuration.

There are few things that I'm a bit unsure about:

1. The implementation of the `Instances` interface. It's not extensively documented, it's not really clear what the different functions are used for, and my questions on the ML didn't get an answer.

2. Counter to the comments on the `LoadBalancers` Interface, I modify the `api.Service` object in `EnsureLoadBalancerDeleted`, but not with the intention of affecting Kube's view of the Service. I simply do it so that I can remove the `Port`s on the `Service` object and then re-use my reconciliation logic that can handle removing stale/deleted Ports. 

3. The logging is a bit verbose. I'm looking for guidance on the appropriate log level to use for the chattier bits.

Due to the (current) lack of Instance Metadata Service and lack of Virtual Machine Identity in Azure, the user is required to do a few things to opt-in to this provider. These things are called-out as they are in contrast to AWS/GCE:

1. The user must provision an Azure Active Directory ServicePrincipal with `Contributor` level access to the resource group that the cluster is deployed in. This creation process is documented [by Hashicorp](https://www.packer.io/docs/builders/azure-setup.html) or [on the MSDN Blog](https://blogs.msdn.microsoft.com/arsen/2016/05/11/how-to-create-and-test-azure-service-principal-using-azure-cli/).

2. The user must place a JSON file somewhere on each Node that conforms to the `AzureConfig` struct defined in `azure.go`. (This is automatically done in the Azure flavor of [Kubernetes-Anywhere](https://github.com/kubernetes/kubernetes-anywhere).)

3. The user must specify `--cloud-config=/path/to/azure.json` as an option to `kube-apiserver` and `kube-controller-manager` similarly to how the user would need to pass `--cloud-provider=azure`.

I've been running approximately this code for a month and a half. I only encountered one bug which has since been fixed and covered by a unit test. I've just deployed a new cluster (and a Type=LoadBalancer nginx Service) using this code (via `kubernetes-anywhere`) and have posted [the `kube-controller-manager` logs](https://gist.github.com/colemickens/1bf6a26e7ef9484a72a30b1fcf9fc3cb) for anyone who is interested in seeing the logs of the logic.

If you're interested in this PR, you can use the instructions in my [`azure-kubernetes-demo` repository](https://github.com/colemickens/azure-kubernetes-demo) to deploy a cluster with minimal effort via [`kubernetes-anywhere`](https://github.com/kubernetes/kubernetes-anywhere). (There is currently [a pending PR in `kubernetes-anywhere` that is needed](kubernetes-retired/kubernetes-anywhere#172) in conjuncture with this PR). I also have a pre-built `hyperkube` image: `docker.io/colemickens/hyperkube-amd64:v1.4.0-alpha.0-azure`, which will be kept in sync with the branch this PR stems from.

I'm hoping this can land in the Kubernetes 1.4 timeframe.

CC (potential code reviewers from Azure): @ahmetalpbalkan @brendandixon @paulmey

CC (other interested Azure folk): @brendandburns @johngossman @anandramakrishna @jmspring @jimzim

CC (others who've expressed interest): @codefx9 @edevil @thockin @rootfs
dims pushed a commit to dims/openstack-cloud-controller-manager that referenced this pull request Sep 6, 2017
Automatic merge from submit-queue

Add an Azure CloudProvider Implementation

This PR adds `Azure` as a cloudprovider provider for Kubernetes. It specifically adds support for native pod networking (via Azure User Defined Routes) and L4 Load Balancing (via Azure Load Balancers).

I did have to add `clusterName` as a parameter to the `LoadBalancers` methods. This is because Azure only allows one "LoadBalancer" object per set of backend machines. This means a single "LoadBalancer" object must be shared across the cluster. The "LoadBalancer" is named via the `cluster-name` parameter passed to `kube-controller-manager` so as to enable multiple clusters per resource group if the user desires such a configuration.

There are few things that I'm a bit unsure about:

1. The implementation of the `Instances` interface. It's not extensively documented, it's not really clear what the different functions are used for, and my questions on the ML didn't get an answer.

2. Counter to the comments on the `LoadBalancers` Interface, I modify the `api.Service` object in `EnsureLoadBalancerDeleted`, but not with the intention of affecting Kube's view of the Service. I simply do it so that I can remove the `Port`s on the `Service` object and then re-use my reconciliation logic that can handle removing stale/deleted Ports. 

3. The logging is a bit verbose. I'm looking for guidance on the appropriate log level to use for the chattier bits.

Due to the (current) lack of Instance Metadata Service and lack of Virtual Machine Identity in Azure, the user is required to do a few things to opt-in to this provider. These things are called-out as they are in contrast to AWS/GCE:

1. The user must provision an Azure Active Directory ServicePrincipal with `Contributor` level access to the resource group that the cluster is deployed in. This creation process is documented [by Hashicorp](https://www.packer.io/docs/builders/azure-setup.html) or [on the MSDN Blog](https://blogs.msdn.microsoft.com/arsen/2016/05/11/how-to-create-and-test-azure-service-principal-using-azure-cli/).

2. The user must place a JSON file somewhere on each Node that conforms to the `AzureConfig` struct defined in `azure.go`. (This is automatically done in the Azure flavor of [Kubernetes-Anywhere](https://github.com/kubernetes/kubernetes-anywhere).)

3. The user must specify `--cloud-config=/path/to/azure.json` as an option to `kube-apiserver` and `kube-controller-manager` similarly to how the user would need to pass `--cloud-provider=azure`.

I've been running approximately this code for a month and a half. I only encountered one bug which has since been fixed and covered by a unit test. I've just deployed a new cluster (and a Type=LoadBalancer nginx Service) using this code (via `kubernetes-anywhere`) and have posted [the `kube-controller-manager` logs](https://gist.github.com/colemickens/1bf6a26e7ef9484a72a30b1fcf9fc3cb) for anyone who is interested in seeing the logs of the logic.

If you're interested in this PR, you can use the instructions in my [`azure-kubernetes-demo` repository](https://github.com/colemickens/azure-kubernetes-demo) to deploy a cluster with minimal effort via [`kubernetes-anywhere`](https://github.com/kubernetes/kubernetes-anywhere). (There is currently [a pending PR in `kubernetes-anywhere` that is needed](kubernetes-retired/kubernetes-anywhere#172) in conjuncture with this PR). I also have a pre-built `hyperkube` image: `docker.io/colemickens/hyperkube-amd64:v1.4.0-alpha.0-azure`, which will be kept in sync with the branch this PR stems from.

I'm hoping this can land in the Kubernetes 1.4 timeframe.

CC (potential code reviewers from Azure): @ahmetalpbalkan @brendandixon @paulmey

CC (other interested Azure folk): @brendandburns @johngossman @anandramakrishna @jmspring @jimzim

CC (others who've expressed interest): @codefx9 @edevil @thockin @rootfs
dims pushed a commit to dims/openstack-cloud-controller-manager that referenced this pull request Jan 13, 2018
Automatic merge from submit-queue

Add an Azure CloudProvider Implementation

This PR adds `Azure` as a cloudprovider provider for Kubernetes. It specifically adds support for native pod networking (via Azure User Defined Routes) and L4 Load Balancing (via Azure Load Balancers).

I did have to add `clusterName` as a parameter to the `LoadBalancers` methods. This is because Azure only allows one "LoadBalancer" object per set of backend machines. This means a single "LoadBalancer" object must be shared across the cluster. The "LoadBalancer" is named via the `cluster-name` parameter passed to `kube-controller-manager` so as to enable multiple clusters per resource group if the user desires such a configuration.

There are few things that I'm a bit unsure about:

1. The implementation of the `Instances` interface. It's not extensively documented, it's not really clear what the different functions are used for, and my questions on the ML didn't get an answer.

2. Counter to the comments on the `LoadBalancers` Interface, I modify the `api.Service` object in `EnsureLoadBalancerDeleted`, but not with the intention of affecting Kube's view of the Service. I simply do it so that I can remove the `Port`s on the `Service` object and then re-use my reconciliation logic that can handle removing stale/deleted Ports. 

3. The logging is a bit verbose. I'm looking for guidance on the appropriate log level to use for the chattier bits.

Due to the (current) lack of Instance Metadata Service and lack of Virtual Machine Identity in Azure, the user is required to do a few things to opt-in to this provider. These things are called-out as they are in contrast to AWS/GCE:

1. The user must provision an Azure Active Directory ServicePrincipal with `Contributor` level access to the resource group that the cluster is deployed in. This creation process is documented [by Hashicorp](https://www.packer.io/docs/builders/azure-setup.html) or [on the MSDN Blog](https://blogs.msdn.microsoft.com/arsen/2016/05/11/how-to-create-and-test-azure-service-principal-using-azure-cli/).

2. The user must place a JSON file somewhere on each Node that conforms to the `AzureConfig` struct defined in `azure.go`. (This is automatically done in the Azure flavor of [Kubernetes-Anywhere](https://github.com/kubernetes/kubernetes-anywhere).)

3. The user must specify `--cloud-config=/path/to/azure.json` as an option to `kube-apiserver` and `kube-controller-manager` similarly to how the user would need to pass `--cloud-provider=azure`.

I've been running approximately this code for a month and a half. I only encountered one bug which has since been fixed and covered by a unit test. I've just deployed a new cluster (and a Type=LoadBalancer nginx Service) using this code (via `kubernetes-anywhere`) and have posted [the `kube-controller-manager` logs](https://gist.github.com/colemickens/1bf6a26e7ef9484a72a30b1fcf9fc3cb) for anyone who is interested in seeing the logs of the logic.

If you're interested in this PR, you can use the instructions in my [`azure-kubernetes-demo` repository](https://github.com/colemickens/azure-kubernetes-demo) to deploy a cluster with minimal effort via [`kubernetes-anywhere`](https://github.com/kubernetes/kubernetes-anywhere). (There is currently [a pending PR in `kubernetes-anywhere` that is needed](kubernetes-retired/kubernetes-anywhere#172) in conjuncture with this PR). I also have a pre-built `hyperkube` image: `docker.io/colemickens/hyperkube-amd64:v1.4.0-alpha.0-azure`, which will be kept in sync with the branch this PR stems from.

I'm hoping this can land in the Kubernetes 1.4 timeframe.

CC (potential code reviewers from Azure): @ahmetalpbalkan @brendandixon @paulmey

CC (other interested Azure folk): @brendandburns @johngossman @anandramakrishna @jmspring @jimzim

CC (others who've expressed interest): @codefx9 @edevil @thockin @rootfs
Sign up for free to subscribe to this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in.
Labels
None yet
Projects
None yet
Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

3 participants