H264 decoder behaves incorrectly when reconfigured with different aspect ratio #2003
Open
Description
Version
Media3 main branch
More version details
Media3 1.1.x
Media3 1.3.x
Media3 1.4.x
Media3 1.5.x
Media3 1.6.0-alpha1
Devices that reproduce the issue
Devices with c2.exynos.h264.decoder that reproduce the issue
- Pixel 7 Pro (Android 14 - 15)
- Pixel 8 Pro (Android 14 - 15)
Devices with c2.android.avc.decoder that reproduce the issue
- Pixel 4A (Android 14)
- Pixel 6 Pro (Android 14)
- Pixel 7 Pro (Android 14 - 15)
- Pixel 8 Pro (Android 14 - 15)
- Poco F3 (Android 13)
- Poco M5 (Android 13)
- Poco X6 Pro (Android 14)
- Xiaomi A3 (Android 11)
- Xiaomi 13T (Android 14)
- Xiaomi Redmi 8 Pro (Android 14)
- Xiaomi Redmi Note 9s (Android 12)
- Vivo Y33s (Android 13)
- Vivo x Flip (Android 14)
- One Plus 7 pro (Android 11)
- Nothing Phone 1 (Android 13)
- Samsung A50 (Android 11)
- Samsung S23 Ultra (Android 14)
- Motorola Razr 50 Ultra (Android 14)
- Android Studio Emulators (Android 12 - 15, also maybe less 12)
Devices that do not reproduce the issue
No response
Reproducible in the demo app?
Yes
Reproduction steps
It is easier to test using the sample app: https://github.com/vladikadiroff/media3-issue,
but you can also reproduce this in "demo-session" app by replacing the source links and attach MediaCodecSelector from https://gist.github.com/vladikadiroff/45daf4d68d8bcb4b1baffed63a433cd2.
- Open the app
- Click next button until the 3rd video appears
- Playback failed
Expected result
Playlist is playing normally
with_fix.mp4
Actual result
Playback failed
issue.mp4
Media
Sample App:
media3-h264-broken.apk.zip
MediaCodecSelector for Reproduction:
https://gist.github.com/vladikadiroff/45daf4d68d8bcb4b1baffed63a433cd2
Media URLs:
https://bl.rutube.ru/route/2ff1f14bfebbe5634d278c648cc6de86.m3u8?guids=b90d44fe-f06e-4c7f-a581-c7116d1a473c_608x1080_1519012_D39667_B1314619A192000_F30A44100_avc1.640029_mp4a.40.2,0ce1b425-a61f-40af-8910-963a9b184e93_136x240_361044_D39667_B289700A64200_F30A44100_avc1.42c01f_mp4a.40.2,9617f7f1-55cf-492e-b587-f422553a6522_408x720_940485_D39667_B736087A192000_F30A44100_avc1.640029_mp4a.40.2,88b6838a-9bcb-46f0-b722-4f9b593ffbd7_208x360_501465_D39667_B430120A64200_F30A44100_avc1.42c01f_mp4a.40.2,60f244aa-3163-435b-b8cf-74d35be010f5_816x1440_2249244_D39667_B2044856A192000_F30A44100_avc1.640034_mp4a.40.2,f22360d9-dd6c-4c35-a936-b359c08f96e6_88x144_172858_D39667_B101511A64200_F30A44100_avc1.42c01f_mp4a.40.2,a1f7dca1-eb55-4827-9e2d-2ed3450e1605_272x480_568444_D39667_B431229A128119_F30A44100_avc1.4d401f_mp4a.40.2&sign=vP2Vz8QlYBIODz-wdpuvlQ&expire=2020699397&guarantee=7&scheme=https&minimal_long_temperature=300000
https://bl.rutube.ru/route/c2cf2d92119ccab132ad699458451fce.m3u8?guids=87e6d49e-1696-49bb-a453-47f02e3828b3_256x144_371448_D6765360_B236316A64000_F25A44100_avc1.42c01f_mp4a.40.2,ef7dfe4e-f9b0-40d2-b551-fc11a6aa90a8_432x232_642613_D6765360_B507481A64000_F25A44100_avc1.42c01f_mp4a.40.2,d42dab1b-3865-4519-9417-f878d196f742_640x360_1084340_D6765360_B949208A64000_F25A44100_avc1.42c01f_mp4a.40.2,548fa999-fce5-4c71-a37b-ca533f36b05b_856x480_1232930_D6765360_B968230A128000_F25A44100_avc1.4d401f_mp4a.40.2,519407aa-7bf6-490b-aa2f-d70c242466f5_1280x720_2070581_D6765360_B1677879A192000_F25A44100_avc1.640029_mp4a.40.2,14da8ad5-f497-42e9-9ab4-5b8c873e53e8_1920x1080_3890152_D6765360_B3497450A192000_F25A44100_avc1.640029_mp4a.40.2&sign=rq6XzKCy5PYfIyXf_9_8tA&expire=2020699377&guarantee=6&scheme=https&minimal_long_temperature=300000
https://bl.rutube.ru/route/192d0fe316aa7a2ab770ce578f5a7540.m3u8?guids=ddc15d68-e53e-48f9-bae6-e031da021cc2_256x144_568311_D5503120_B433178A64000_F25A44100_avc1.42c01f_mp4a.40.2,00192241-2eda-422b-b84d-3438cb624c72_432x232_1045583_D5503120_B910450A64000_F25A44100_avc1.42c01f_mp4a.40.2,62c27499-607b-48d2-9689-feb56c82e354_640x360_1776586_D5503120_B1641453A64000_F25A44100_avc1.42c01f_mp4a.40.2,6b0e22b1-7b74-4332-95a4-1bf526f5f902_1920x1080_5616400_D5503120_B5223696A192000_F25A44100_avc1.640029_mp4a.40.2,9963f111-6b1a-4fb5-86ae-2b715b9a6a08_856x480_1862389_D5503120_B1597687A128000_F25A44100_avc1.4d401f_mp4a.40.2,57d0d863-19e5-4db1-bc75-8b85da6a4741_1280x720_3024962_D5503120_B2632259A192000_F25A44100_avc1.640029_mp4a.40.2&sign=hEvSYkYZIJPQaUvRW3XFDA&expire=2020699353&guarantee=6&scheme=https&minimal_long_temperature=300000
https://bl.rutube.ru/route/4c9da41e277d036cb6bffc17a01ed1d9.m3u8?guids=058d4f53-8f85-4ffe-8857-16ea89398fca_272x480_488270_D33025_B385337A96000_F30A44100_avc1.4d401f_mp4a.40.2,47efff58-a2ff-458d-a339-9e4f0b0af650_88x144_173302_D33025_B102546A64155_F30A44100_avc1.42c01f_mp4a.40.2,461c6f6f-d208-45c2-b598-8ec62f2f5cbe_208x360_502295_D33025_B433457A64155_F30A44100_avc1.42c01f_mp4a.40.2,6e745cc6-105b-4219-886f-bcebf012870b_408x720_845200_D33025_B744348A96000_F30A44100_avc1.640029_mp4a.40.2,a7f732b6-9422-40fd-9789-1e1fd5e55f87_608x1080_1625210_D33025_B1528911A96000_F30A44100_avc1.640029_mp4a.40.2,dbf26a41-ec66-4f6b-a54f-a2bfc4c01d0a_136x240_376925_D33025_B307357A64155_F30A44100_avc1.42c01f_mp4a.40.2&sign=cqHoZkCOPkFCmkua5GP6eg&expire=2020699329&guarantee=6&scheme=https&minimal_long_temperature=300000
Bug Report
- You will email the zip file produced by
adb bugreportto android-media-github@google.com after filing this issue.