Skip to content

Input {48, MemoryConstrained[...]} cannot be evaluated, cause: {HoldForm[MessageName[ForAll, "msgs"]]} #109

Open
@krooken

Description

I am getting an error message that I cannot understand. I am trying to prove a seemingly simple formula where I have, among others, yp < 0 and yp >= 0 on the left hand side. When I try to close the branch with QE, I get an error saying Input {48, MemoryConstrained[...]} cannot be evaluated, cause: {HoldForm[MessageName[ForAll, "msgs"]]}. What does this error message mean? If I hide some of the sequents, then I can close the branch with QE, but I am a bit suprised that I have to. I think that I have managed to close similar branched before; what is special about this formula?

KeYmaera X version 5.0.1
Operating System:
Windows 10 10.0
Java JVM:
Oracle Corporation 17.0.1 with 64 bits
Java Home:
C:\Program Files\Java\jdk-17.0.1

Input {48, MemoryConstrained[TimeConstrained[Reduce[ForAll[{kyxyp, kyxxp, kyxx, kyxwl, kyxvpMax, kyxv, kyxt$u$, kyxrange, kyxptol, kyxle, kyxaMin, kyxaMax, kyxa, kyxT}, Implies[And[Greater[kyxwl, 0], And[Greater[kyxle, 0], And[Greater[kyxvpMax, 0], And[Greater[kyxrange, 0], And[Greater[kyxptol, 0], And[Less[kyxaMin, 0], And[Greater[kyxaMax, 0], And[Less[Times[kyxT, kyxvpMax], kyxwl], And[Less[Times[kyxT, Minus[0]], kyxwl], And[Greater[kyxxp, kyxrange], And[Greater[kyxT, 0], And[Less[kyxyp, 0], And[GreaterEqual[kyxt$u$, 0], And[ForAll[{kyxs$u$}, Implies[And[LessEqual[0, kyxs$u$], LessEqual[kyxs$u$, kyxt$u$]], And[LessEqual[Plus[kyxs$u$, 0], kyxT], GreaterEqual[Plus[Times[kyxaMax, kyxs$u$], kyxv], 0]]]], And[LessEqual[Subtract[kyxx, kyxle], kyxxp], And[GreaterEqual[kyxyp, 0], And[LessEqual[kyxyp, kyxwl], And[Greater[kyxyp, kyxwl], And[Implies[Less[kyxyp, 0], Greater[Plus[Divide[Times[Times[kyxaMax, Minus[Divide[kyxyp, kyxvpMax]]], Minus[Divide[kyxyp, kyxvpMax]]], 2], Times[kyxv, Minus[Divide[kyxyp, kyxvpMax]]]], Plus[Subtract[kyxxp, kyxx], kyxle]]], And[Greater[0, 0], And[Less[0, kyxvpMax], And[LessEqual[kyxaMin, kyxa], And[LessEqual[kyxa, kyxaMax], And[Implies[Greater[kyxyp, kyxwl], Greater[Plus[Divide[Times[Times[kyxaMax, Divide[Subtract[kyxyp, kyxwl], Minus[0]]], Divide[Subtract[kyxyp, kyxwl], Minus[0]]], 2], Times[kyxv, Divide[Subtract[kyxyp, kyxwl], Minus[0]]]], Plus[Subtract[kyxxp, kyxx], kyxle]]], Implies[And[GreaterEqual[kyxyp, 0], LessEqual[kyxyp, kyxwl]], Greater[Subtract[kyxx, kyxle], kyxxp]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]], Greater[Plus[Divide[Times[Times[kyxaMax, Divide[Subtract[kyxyp, kyxwl], Minus[0]]], Divide[Subtract[kyxyp, kyxwl], Minus[0]]], 2], Times[Plus[Times[kyxaMax, kyxt$u$], kyxv], Divide[Subtract[kyxyp, kyxwl], Minus[0]]]], Plus[Subtract[kyxxp, Plus[Plus[Times[kyxaMax, Divide[Power[kyxt$u$, 2], 2]], Times[kyxv, kyxt$u$]], kyxx]], kyxle]]]], {}, Reals], 5], 8000000000]} cannot be evaluated, cause: {HoldForm[MessageName[ForAll, "msgs"]]} in _QE in _QE at edu.cmu.cs.ls.keymaerax.bellerophon.BelleBaseInterpreter.runExpr(SequentialInterpreter.scala:296) at edu.cmu.cs.ls.keymaerax.bellerophon.SequentialInterpreter.runExpr(SequentialInterpreter.scala:773) at edu.cmu.cs.ls.keymaerax.bellerophon.ExhaustiveSequentialInterpreter.runExpr(SequentialInterpreter.scala:813) at edu.cmu.cs.ls.keymaerax.bellerophon.BelleBaseInterpreter.apply(SequentialInterpreter.scala:45) at edu.cmu.cs.ls.keymaerax.bellerophon.BelleBaseInterpreter.runExpr(SequentialInterpreter.scala:291) at edu.cmu.cs.ls.keymaerax.bellerophon.SequentialInterpreter.runExpr(SequentialInterpreter.scala:773) at edu.cmu.cs.ls.keymaerax.bellerophon.ExhaustiveSequentialInterpreter.runExpr(SequentialInterpreter.scala:813) at edu.cmu.cs.ls.keymaerax.bellerophon.BelleBaseInterpreter.apply(SequentialInterpreter.scala:45) at edu.cmu.cs.ls.keymaerax.bellerophon.BelleBaseInterpreter.runExpr(SequentialInterpreter.scala:308) at edu.cmu.cs.ls.keymaerax.bellerophon.SequentialInterpreter.runExpr(SequentialInterpreter.scala:773) at edu.cmu.cs.ls.keymaerax.bellerophon.ExhaustiveSequentialInterpreter.runExpr(SequentialInterpreter.scala:813) at edu.cmu.cs.ls.keymaerax.bellerophon.BelleBaseInterpreter.apply(SequentialInterpreter.scala:45) at edu.cmu.cs.ls.keymaerax.hydra.BellerophonTacticExecutor$$anon$1.call(BellerophonTacticExecutor.scala:128) at edu.cmu.cs.ls.keymaerax.hydra.BellerophonTacticExecutor$$anon$1.call(BellerophonTacticExecutor.scala:125) at java.base/java.util.concurrent.FutureTask.run(FutureTask.java:264) at java.base/java.util.concurrent.Executors$RunnableAdapter.call(Executors.java:539) at java.base/java.util.concurrent.FutureTask.run(FutureTask.java:264) at java.base/java.util.concurrent.ThreadPoolExecutor.runWorker(ThreadPoolExecutor.java:1136) at java.base/java.util.concurrent.ThreadPoolExecutor$Worker.run(ThreadPoolExecutor.java:635) at java.base/java.lang.Thread.run(Thread.java:833) Caused by: Input {48, MemoryConstrained[TimeConstrained[Reduce[ForAll[{kyxyp, kyxxp, kyxx, kyxwl, kyxvpMax, kyxv, kyxt$u$, kyxrange, kyxptol, kyxle, kyxaMin, kyxaMax, kyxa, kyxT}, Implies[And[Greater[kyxwl, 0], And[Greater[kyxle, 0], And[Greater[kyxvpMax, 0], And[Greater[kyxrange, 0], And[Greater[kyxptol, 0], And[Less[kyxaMin, 0], And[Greater[kyxaMax, 0], And[Less[Times[kyxT, kyxvpMax], kyxwl], And[Less[Times[kyxT, Minus[0]], kyxwl], And[Greater[kyxxp, kyxrange], And[Greater[kyxT, 0], And[Less[kyxyp, 0], And[GreaterEqual[kyxt$u$, 0], And[ForAll[{kyxs$u$}, Implies[And[LessEqual[0, kyxs$u$], LessEqual[kyxs$u$, kyxt$u$]], And[LessEqual[Plus[kyxs$u$, 0], kyxT], GreaterEqual[Plus[Times[kyxaMax, kyxs$u$], kyxv], 0]]]], And[LessEqual[Subtract[kyxx, kyxle], kyxxp], And[GreaterEqual[kyxyp, 0], And[LessEqual[kyxyp, kyxwl], And[Greater[kyxyp, kyxwl], And[Implies[Less[kyxyp, 0], Greater[Plus[Divide[Times[Times[kyxaMax, Minus[Divide[kyxyp, kyxvpMax]]], Minus[Divide[kyxyp, kyxvpMax]]], 2], Times[kyxv, Minus[Divide[kyxyp, kyxvpMax]]]], Plus[Subtract[kyxxp, kyxx], kyxle]]], And[Greater[0, 0], And[Less[0, kyxvpMax], And[LessEqual[kyxaMin, kyxa], And[LessEqual[kyxa, kyxaMax], And[Implies[Greater[kyxyp, kyxwl], Greater[Plus[Divide[Times[Times[kyxaMax, Divide[Subtract[kyxyp, kyxwl], Minus[0]]], Divide[Subtract[kyxyp, kyxwl], Minus[0]]], 2], Times[kyxv, Divide[Subtract[kyxyp, kyxwl], Minus[0]]]], Plus[Subtract[kyxxp, kyxx], kyxle]]], Implies[And[GreaterEqual[kyxyp, 0], LessEqual[kyxyp, kyxwl]], Greater[Subtract[kyxx, kyxle], kyxxp]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]], Greater[Plus[Divide[Times[Times[kyxaMax, Divide[Subtract[kyxyp, kyxwl], Minus[0]]], Divide[Subtract[kyxyp, kyxwl], Minus[0]]], 2], Times[Plus[Times[kyxaMax, kyxt$u$], kyxv], Divide[Subtract[kyxyp, kyxwl], Minus[0]]]], Plus[Subtract[kyxxp, Plus[Plus[Times[kyxaMax, Divide[Power[kyxt$u$, 2], 2]], Times[kyxv, kyxt$u$]], kyxx]], kyxle]]]], {}, Reals], 5], 8000000000]} cannot be evaluated, cause: {HoldForm[MessageName[ForAll, "msgs"]]}
at edu.cmu.cs.ls.keymaerax.tools.qe.JLinkMathematicaCommandRunner.$anonfun$getAnswer$1(MathematicaCommandRunner.scala:150)
at edu.cmu.cs.ls.keymaerax.tools.qe.MathematicaConversion$.importResult(MathematicaConversion.scala:33)
at edu.cmu.cs.ls.keymaerax.tools.qe.JLinkMathematicaCommandRunner.getAnswer(MathematicaCommandRunner.scala:137)
at edu.cmu.cs.ls.keymaerax.tools.qe.JLinkMathematicaCommandRunner.doRun(MathematicaCommandRunner.scala:87)
at edu.cmu.cs.ls.keymaerax.tools.qe.BaseMathematicaCommandRunner.run(MathematicaCommandRunner.scala:51)
at edu.cmu.cs.ls.keymaerax.tools.qe.MathematicaQETool.singleQE(MathematicaQETool.scala:49)
at edu.cmu.cs.ls.keymaerax.tools.qe.MathematicaQETool.quantifierElimination(MathematicaQETool.scala:34)
at edu.cmu.cs.ls.keymaerax.core.Provable$.proveArithmetic(Proof.scala:521)
at edu.cmu.cs.ls.keymaerax.pt.ElidingProvable$.proveArithmetic(TermProvable.scala:439)
at edu.cmu.cs.ls.keymaerax.pt.ElidingProvable$.proveArithmeticLemma(TermProvable.scala:442)
at edu.cmu.cs.ls.keymaerax.pt.ProvableSig$.proveArithmeticLemma(TermProvable.scala:371)
at edu.cmu.cs.ls.keymaerax.tools.ext.Mathematica.$anonfun$qe$1(Mathematica.scala:132)
at edu.cmu.cs.ls.keymaerax.tools.ext.MathematicaQEToolBridge.$anonfun$run$1(MathematicaQEToolBridge.scala:29)
at edu.cmu.cs.ls.keymaerax.tools.ext.JLinkMathematicaLink.$anonfun$run$2(MathematicaLink.scala:316)
at edu.cmu.cs.ls.keymaerax.tools.ext.ToolExecutor.$anonfun$makeFuture$1(ToolExecutor.scala:111)
... 6 more

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions